Durant with Pippen's Defense or Nash with Payton's Defense?

[AirTupac]

Who would you choose?

[JohnFreeman]

So, LeBron and CP3? just joking

[Andrei89]

So, LeBron and CP3?

[AirTupac]

So, LeBron and CP3?

Not even close

[CrazyLond]

I would take Durant with Pippen's defense.

[Harison]

Big > small, if relative talent is comparable.

[NumberSix]

Pippen with Durant's officiating >

[Kblaze8855]

Paytons defense wouldnt be allowed today. Some of Pippens would be removed but so much of his impact was talking, passing lanes, being versatile, quick to rotate, and crazy agile for his size it would translate better to a softer era.

[Milbuck]

Pippen's defense is obviously on another level compared to Durant, but we have to consider that Durant is for the most part an above average defender. Nash is/was a complete liability, one of the worst defenders out there. Even with this, his impact on the game was massive. Offensively he was beyond stats. He was so supremely gifted at running an offense that he could have 15 points and 10 assists, a pretty average point guard statline, and he'd still have dominated the game on offense. Now we're giving him the GOAT defense for his position, not only negating his one weakness, but making it just as strong as his incredible offense? That's absurd. I'd probably still take Durant, but it'd be a very tough decision.

This is all assuming that GP and Pippen's defense wouldn't be compromised in this bullshit era, which they probably would be.

[riseagainst]

Durant with Pippen's defense is easily the GOAT level wing player and it's not even close, yes I said it. Even greater than MJ. Too bad you can't fuse people.

[pauk]

Durant with Pippen's defense is easily the GOAT level wing player and it's not even close, yes I said it. Even greater than MJ. Too bad you can't fuse people.

So basically you think Lebron is greater than MJ? Hell you get also extra offense (passing/vision/IQ) with Lebron aswell....

[russwest0]

So basically you think Lebron is greater than MJ? Hell you get also extra offense (passing/vision/IQ) with Lebron aswell....

^This guy actually believes that LeBron is Pippen + Durant + Stockton

[TheMan]

So basically you think Lebron is greater than MJ? Hell you get also extra offense (passing/vision/IQ) with Lebron aswell....

GTFO Pauk.

LeBron is still probably the better overall player but he isn't as good of a pure scorer as Durant and he isn't on Pippen's defensive level.

[TheMan]

^This guy actually believes that LeBron is Pippen + Durant + Stockton

Pretty much, he's ISH's biggest Bran Stan.

[iamgine]

Steve Nash was the most incredible offensive player I've ever seen post rule change in '05. Not Kobe, Durant or Lebron.

If there's a knock on him it's probably he's a late bloomer and he's not the most durable guy. Also his defense was not good and the rule change might have benefited his game greatly.