Who Ya Got: Westbrook Or Healthy Rose

[Solefade]

Derrick Rose

-better in the fast break
-finisher
-scorer
-passer
-much better handles

Better in fast break, finisher, passer, handles? That's all debatable...Yeah, Rose is probably a better scorer because he's the man on his team but WB is bigger, stronger, and has a post game.

[Bigsmoke]

Better in fast break, finisher, passer, handles? That's all debatable...Yeah, Rose is probably a better scorer because he's the man on his team but WB is bigger, stronger, and has a post game.

their handles ARE NOT on the same level... at all

Westbrook's handles are hella averaged for an all star PG.

[tikay0]

Better in fast break, finisher, passer, handles? That's all debatable...Yeah, Rose is probably a better scorer because he's the man on his team but WB is bigger, stronger, and has a post game.

He's not stronger at all, and what post game? He speeds up the court and shoots jumpers with 20 second left on the clock for goodness sake.

A few thunderous dunks = stronger to you? Rose is the much better player, playing through contact. Not even debatable.

P4P, other than Nate Robinson, I think Rose is the strongest player in the league.

[tikay0]

their handles ARE NOT on the same level... at all

Westbrook's handles are hella averaged for an all star PG.

Exactly this. Westbrook has handles?

Can you please show a video with these exceptional handles?

Westbrook is like Lebron in the handles category. Rose is like Kobe.

You can't compare a stiff athlete to an athlete that uses poetry in motion cheat codes.

[tikay0]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHpyWznr-ZM

Compared to this.......

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlXvJptYA_Y


Not even debatable.

[tikay0]

You guys are also forgetting the amount of spacing Westbrook gets compared to Rose.

[tpols]

Derrick rose should be healthier than westbrook.. He has had twice the time to heal from the same injury.

But I think westbrook will still come back stronger

[Fudge]

1. Russell Westbrook









2. Derrick Rose

[tikay0]

Derrick rose should be healthier than westbrook.. He has had twice the time to heal from the same injury.

But I think westbrook will still come back stronger

Obivously. Complete ACL tear with partial MCL tear compared to mild MCL.

[Young X]

Westbrook and Rose are basically equals, they're production, and impact are the exact same. Westbrook is a better all-around player, but Rose is smarter and a slightly better offensive player. I might take Rose because I trust his decision making more, but other than media hype they've been the exact same since 2011.

[Solefade]

He's not stronger at all, and what post game? He speeds up the court and shoots jumpers with 20 second left on the clock for goodness sake.

A few thunderous dunks = stronger to you? Rose is the much better player, playing through contact. Not even debatable.

P4P, other than Nate Robinson, I think Rose is the strongest player in the league.

Lol you probably don't watch enough Westbrook, dude has been posting up since like 2008 or 2009 (He wasn't very good at it then but he's decent now) and don't tell me you've been following if you just watch YouTube clips of him. He pounds on anyone that's smaller than him.

Everyone overrates Rose like a mofo on this forum.

[tpols]

Obivously. Complete ACL tear with partial MCL tear compared to mild MCL.

Alright than westbrook will be better than him again like he has been the past two years

[SillyRabbit]

Westbrook can do everything Rose can. You switch Rose and WB from their respective teams and WB would probably have the same production as Rose did. Plus he's a lot more durable it seems and plays better defense.

This.

I'd take Westbrook.

[Jameerthefear]

Rose.

[tikay0]

Alright than westbrook will be better than him again like he has been the past two years

We'll see.