Prime Dominique Wilkins vs. Prime Carmelo Anthony

[Xiao Yao You]

grant hill and Stockton sure are not better than melo.

Carmelo is just another high scoring sf. Stockton is arguably the best pg not named Magic. Grant Hill was also a special player before he got hurt.

[JBrizzy]

When I think back to the old days with your Dominiques and your Jordans, I think 'Hey, those guys were really good players'.

But at the same time, I was a kid, so back then everyone was god-like.

I think it's difficult to compare between generations for this very reason.

Dominique and Melo are both on about the same tier. I don't know who is better.

[Xiao Yao You]

I'd put them at about the same level. They are both highly overrated high scoring sf's that don't live up to the hype.

[TheReal Kendall]

Melo>>>>>>>>>>>>Lebron>>>>>>>>MJ>>>>>>>>>>>>Wilkin s>>Kobe


Melo will be the GOAT when it's all said and done.

[Fresh Kid]

Melo>>>>>>>>>>>>Lebron>>>>>>>>MJ>>>>>>>>>>>>Wilkin s>>Kobe


Melo will be the GOAT when it's all said and done.

Even I wont go that far.

[Fresh Kid]

I'll grant you that Carmelo is better than Stockton was, but Grant Hill? Pre-injury, the guy was posting LeBron-like numbers with better rebounding and lesser scoring.

Yes Melo is better than grant hill, most definitely.

[Fresh Kid]

Carmelo is just another high scoring sf. Stockton is arguably the best pg not named Magic. Grant Hill was also a special player before he got hurt.

Grant hill wasnt better than Carmelo Anthony though.

[secund2nun]

Yes Melo is better than grant hill, most definitely.

Prime Hill was way better than Melo. Melo is very overrated. Him playing for huge market NY made it worse as the big market stars always get overrated.

[Xiao Yao You]

He was overrated before going to NY.

[Micku]

From the vids that I watched, Wilkins seemed more athletic. Carmelo had a better jumper and seem to have more ways to score, but Wilkins seemed to score more anyway. Wilkins also get up more for the rebounds.

But I don't know who is the better player. Wilkins is a more exciting player tho.

[Fresh Kid]

Prime Hill was way better than Melo. Melo is very overrated. Him playing for huge market NY made it worse as the big market stars always get overrated.

How was grant hill better than melo? explain Lebron fan.

[Fresh Kid]

He was overrated before going to NY.

he had 40 and 50 point games, never missed playoffs, multiple all star, and led a team to the western finals for crying out loud.

[SamuraiSWISH]

I'm going with Nique. Not by a lot, they are very similar. Prime Hill btw is absolutely a better basketball player than Carmelo Anthony. Anyone insinuating otherwise never saw Hill, or is flat out a stan for Melo ... possibly even retarded.

[secund2nun]

How was grant hill better than melo? explain Lebron fan.

He was a much more complete player. His passing was a lot better, his rebounding was better and his defense was better.

[IncarceratedBob]

LeBron wouldn't be a top 6 player in the 90's

Jordan
Magic
Malone
Barkley
Shaq
Hakeem

Sorry.