Derrick Rose is the best dunking PG to play in the NBA.

[memetherapy]

Am I the only one here who thinks dunking is really not the thing we should be comparing PGs by ?

No, you're not. But you are the only one here who's presupposing everyone else is judging the players' calibres based on their dunking prowess. So, in the end, yes, you're special, just not in the way you'd want to be.

[dbk123]

look at this westbrook windmill
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbPG6VYtsRU

westbrook can jump off one or two feet, while rose is only a 2foot jumper

[eurobum]

Rose. Dat poetry in motion, moves like a cheetah, so beautiful to watch. Someone complained he didn't do posters: how about two legit 7-footers Oden and Joel Anthony.

And how about number two in the first link in the OP, that was nasty. That in-air adjustment. Steve Kerr was just laughing at how ridiculous that play was, athletically.

[jzek]

Westbrook is two inches taller than Rose.

Rose is shorter and lighter and yet still has more power in his dunks than the bigger Westbrook. Rose dunks like a PF or C while Westbrook dunks like a guard/forward.

[dbk123]

Westbrook is two inches taller than Rose.

Rose is shorter and lighter and yet still has more power in his dunks than the bigger Westbrook. Rose dunks like a PF or C while Westbrook dunks like a guard/forward.

hes an inch taller

rose is 6'2.5" while westbrook is 6'3.5

[veilside23]

it has to be steve francis dude only lost to the best dunker ever in vince carter..

if not then you must be 8 years old

check this out

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aY4k0QttPi8

[Cali Syndicate]

Rose is a Steve franchise type dunker with marbur's willingness to facilitate. Best of both worlds.

Per the video the above poster gave , steve francis not only brought it during the all star dunk off but in games as well.

[Bucket_Nakedz]

Rose. Dat poetry in motion, moves like a cheetah, so beautiful to watch. Someone complained he didn't do posters: how about two legit 7-footers Oden and Joel Anthony.

And how about number two in the first link in the OP, that was nasty. That in-air adjustment. Steve Kerr was just laughing at how ridiculous that play was, athletically.

joel anthony is no where near 7 feet. maybe 7 feet wing span but not in height. he's around 6'9/10

spudd webb is still the great dunking pg

[TheReal Kendall]

joel anthony is no where near 7 feet. maybe 7 feet wing span but not in height. he's around 6'9/10

spudd webb is still the great dunking pg

Spudd doesn't have any posters. Nobody knew he could dunk until the dunk contest. He's good though but I'm mainly talking bout in-game and posters.

Stevie is good also but I don't feel like he has the power of Rose.

Rose reminds me of Dominique when dunks. It looks like he's angry at the rim.

But It's all preference though. Everyone that was listed are/was great dunkers. I prefer Rose over them though.

[Cali Syndicate]

Spudd doesn't have any posters. Nobody knew he could dunk until the dunk contest. He's good though but I'm mainly talking bout in-game and posters.

Stevie is good also but I don't feel like he has the power of Rose.

Rose reminds me of Dominique when dunks. It looks like he's angry at the rim.

But It's all preference though. Everyone that was listed are/was great dunkers. I prefer Rose over them though.

Rose reminds me of sprewell. Sprewell was a bit angrier and nastier though IMO but very similar.

Rose and Wilkins don't belong in the same sentence tbh.

[Glide2keva]

I prefer Westbrook mostly because I hate Derrick Rose so I can't say he's a better dunker

Eat this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e04uyfgVgjY

[Glide2keva]

look at this westbrook windmill
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbPG6VYtsRU

westbrook can jump off one or two feet, while rose is only a 2foot jumper

Are you sure about that only two foot dunker thing?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhL025ttQQ8

one foot and two foot dunks on this list, #1 and #3 are just disgusting.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t3LFsMydqQ0

[Graviton]

Rose actually has a real 40+ inch vertical and gets his head almost rim level, Westbrook dunks harder but sometimes he barely gets the ball to get clear the rim since his vertical is probably around 35-38. But he has longer arms and is taller than Rose, so he can reach further and make better one handed dunks.

[Euroleague]

Steve Francis.

[Euroleague]

Now that I think about it, this guy was a pretty damn good dunker for a PG also.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aeeD_jTZf74


And this guy was a hell of a damn good dunker, for any position. And he played tons of point guard in his career.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3toFlRh0_J8