Brooks, Cole, Fredette, Irving, Knight, Rubio, Shumpert, Walker

[KingJames99]

Time to rerank, with some additions, listed alphabetically:

Marshon Brooks
Alec Burks
Norris Cole
Jimmy Fredette
Kyrie Irving
Brandon Knight
Ricky Rubio
Iman Shumpert
Isaiah Thomas
Klay Thompson
Kemba Walker

Are you only ranking guards?

[stallionaire]

Rubio



The rest.

[CavaliersFTW]

I think it's more like:

Bibby plays, Knicks 1-3
Bibby out, Knicks 5 -1

Or, more simply

Non-corpse on the court: 5-1
Corpse on the court: 1-3

[CavaliersFTW]

Rubio



The rest.

Have you not seen Irving play? It's one of the two and it is close.

[maybeshewill13]

Kenneth Faried




Everyone else

[jbryan1984]

Irving
Rubio
Knight
Shumpert
Walker
Cole
Brooks
Fredette


*Have not seen much of Walker, Brooks or Fredette this season so just judging on the games I have actually seen for those 3.

[MeLO MvP 15]

Pretty happy with my rankings still. I'd just move up Knight to behind Shumpert.

[bballbball]

Parsons is a top 7 rookie. Watch more ball.

[RedBlackAttack]

Have you not seen Irving play? It's one of the two and it is close.

Not really close at all. At least, not this year. I can only assume that Kyrie will continue to get better, widening the gap. Let's be honest, here.

[no pun intended]

The OP was ranking guards. Don't you guys get it?

[alenleomessi]

Not really close at all. At least, not this year. I can only assume that Kyrie will continue to get better, widening the gap. Let's be honest, here.

Not close at all?
Check out Wolves record without Rubio

[bdreason]

Irving


















everyone else.

[Qwertyazerty]

Not really close at all. At least, not this year. I can only assume that Kyrie will continue to get better, widening the gap. Let's be honest, here.

Statistically Irving has been only better scorer (much better efficiency, really impressif, and more points per game and minute). He has less APG, about the same RPG, less SPG, about the same BPG, about the same TOPG and about the same amount of PF. Meanwhile, Rubio has taken much more charges, is a far better deffender and sets his team offense, not only his offense, in a very mature way.

If you talk about intangibles lets discuss about records.
Minny was 21-20 before Rubio's injury (despite starting the season 0-5 in very close games, with 0 pre-seson).
Now, Minny is 25-33 (4-13 since Rubio's injury), with the same coach, with the same franchise player gettin MVP consideration... They looked clearly better with Ricky both on offense and deffense.

But you come here and state that Irving is a clear cut to ROY and Rubio can't be considered a close second... I agree on Irving being ROY and him having a higher ceilling than Rubio, not on the huge gap between both.