Oscar Robertson:Arguably The Best Of All Time?

[RRR3]

were talking about GOAT, you need to have the rings to be the greatest

He has a ring, first of all, and he's not the GOAT IMO anyways, but not for the "magical ringzzzz!" argument. You can't just dismiss someone or prop someone up solely for rings, you have to consider the circumstances that were in place when they won/didn't win ring(s).

[RRR3]

Jordan, Magic, Kareem, Bird, Russell, Wilt, Shaq, Kobe, and Duncan are clearly better

[Deuce Bigalow]

He has a ring, first of all, and he's not the GOAT IMO anyways, but not for the "magical ringzzzz!" argument. You can't just dismiss someone or prop someone up solely for rings, you have to consider the circumstances that were in place when they won/didn't win ring(s).

1 ring, and that was with Kareem
compared to jordan and kareem with 6, magic and kobe with 5, duncan and shaq with 4, ect

[Deuce Bigalow]

Give me Kobe over Oscar any day

[Deuce Bigalow]

5 championships, 2 without a top 50 player of alltime > oscar's fast paced stats

[RRR3]

Give me Kobe over Oscar any day

Okay. You can have the lesser player if that's what you really want.

[RRR3]

5 championships, 2 without a top 50 player of alltime > oscar's fast paced stats

Pau Gasol is still a future hall of famer. He's not top 50 or anything, but how many players in NBA history can you name who had better careers? It's not like he's some borderline starter or anything.

[Deuce Bigalow]

Pau Gasol is still a future hall of famer. He's not top 50 or anything, but how many players in NBA history can you name who had better careers? It's not like he's some borderline starter or anything.

yeah i know, but he is not top 50, those championships are impressive

[Deuce Bigalow]

Okay. You can have the lesser player if that's what you really want.

lesser player?

the guy with the 5 rings is a lesser player? okay

[RRR3]

yeah i know, but he is not top 50, those championships are impressive

So Kobe still had another hall of famer playing with him. Kthxbai

[RRR3]

lesser player?

the guy with the 5 rings is a lesser player? okay

Robert Horry 7 rings. Derek Fisher 5 rings.

Robert Horry>Derek Fisher=Kobe Bryant

[Deuce Bigalow]

So Kobe still had another hall of famer playing with him. Kthxbai

Jordan had Pippen - top 50, hof
Shaq had Kobe, top 10, hof
Magic had kareem, top 5, hof
Kareem had Magic, top 5, hof
ect

[RRR3]

Kobe has 9 all nba and all defensive teams

your a moron

Kobe doesn't deserve most of those all defensive teams. And at least one of those all nba 1st teams should have been Wade (this past year). Fail.

[Deuce Bigalow]

Oscar has no case over Kobe Bryant
If he has, tell it

[RRR3]

Jordan had Pippen - top 50, hof
Shaq had Kobe, top 10, hof
Magic had kareem, top 5, hof
Kareem had Magic, top 5, hof
ect

Kobe had Shaq-top 7, hof

Conveniently forgot that one, eh?