ROY 2004: Carmelo Anthony or Lebron James?

[Mr Clutch Melo]

Melo stats : 21/6/3 on 42%..Won 43 games and lost to KGs Wolves in the first round.

Cast :
Andre Miller 14/6
Nene 11/6
Camby 8/10/3


Lebron stats : 21/5/6 on 41% Won 35 games, no playoffs.

Cast :
Ricky Davis 15/5/5
Carlos Boozer 15/11
Big Z 15/8

What do you think ?

[Willkill24]

Melo.

[PowerGlove]

I thought it was Melo then and still do now.

[branslowski]

This thread should be good.....



Anyway...LeBron was the ROY the minute he took the stage next to stern at the Draft....Basically, it was his to lose...And Melo did nothing epic enough to take it away from him.

[Jordan-esque]

Guess someone forgot this.

---

Winning MVP is not just about how great a player's STATS are compared to others...

Oh wait a sec...

Winning ROY is not just about how great a player's STATS are... ah forget it.

[Wakko]

I thought it was Melo then and still do now.

[Droid101]

For rookies, it almost always is about stats (because they so frequently aren't on good teams due to how the draft works).

[Lebron23]

For rookies, it almost always is about stats (because they so frequently aren't on good teams due to how the draft works).

QFT

[2LeTTeRS]

Guess someone forgot this.

---

Winning MVP is not just about how great a player's STATS are compared to others...

Oh wait a sec...

Winning ROY is not just about how great a player's STATS are... ah forget it.

Man shut the f[COLOR="Black"]uc[/COLOR]k up. Being an asshole has nothing to do with how good a player is on the court. If you want to fill the board up with threads about all the bad things he's done thats one thing, but don't derail good threads with this bulls[COLOR="Black"]hi[/COLOR]t

[CJ Mustard]

Melo easily.

[2LeTTeRS]

Speaking of 04......whatever happened to KingofVA from the old ezboard days? He was probably the first Bron hater I remember.

And back then I sided with Bron and still do. They were equal as scorers and on the board, but Bron was just a superior playmaker. To me that was enough to give him the nod as ROY.

[The_Yearning]

Melo. That Nuggest team actually made the playoffs in the West lol and have yet to missed the playoffs since his arrival.

[Lebron23]

Melo should have won the Rookie of the Year, but the voters were probably impressed with LeBron because he's the 4th NBA Rookie to average 20-5-5 in his first NBA Season.

[Tarik One]

Winning MVP is not just about how great a player's STATS are compared to others...

Oh wait a sec...

Winning ROY is not just about how great a player's STATS are... ah forget it.

Tired of people making comparisons in retrospect based solely in stats. The Cavs were a piss poor team before LBJ got there and he single handedly brought them to respectability in a single season. Fack the stats

[Wakko]

Melo should have won the Rookie of the Year, but the voters were probably impressed with LeBron because he's the 4th NBA Rookie to average 20-5-5 in his first NBA Season.