Originally Posted by jzek
Simple reason - both never lost in the Finals (the pinnacle of any team sports).
Jordan > Duncan because MJ won the FMVP in each of his title runs whereas Timmy did not win in 2007.
Your favorite player (Kobe, Shaq, LBJ, KAJ, Russell, Wilt, whoever that may be) can't be considered as the GOAT if he has lost in the Finals.
/end of discussion
PS - Havlicek never lost too but he was only FMVP once in 8 titles. Mikan never lost too but he was never FMVP in 5 BAA/NBA titles.
Strong join date to post ratio.