-
Sixers|Eagles|Phillies
-
He didn't deserve his second one no matter how hard you try to deny it.
-
Local High School Star
i agree, his mvp were deserved, too bad the dirk groupies will swarm and inffest this thread in no time.
-
Local High School Star
Originally Posted by Kobe24
He didn't deserve his second one no matter how hard you try to deny it.
let me guess, the guy on your avatar did ? :rollingeyes:
-
Sixers|Eagles|Phillies
Originally Posted by Kobe24
He didn't deserve his second one no matter how hard you try to deny it.
Who did deserve it? Last season the race was close. I compare it to a Kentuck Derby finish where you gotta go to the tapes to see who won.
-
Serious playground baller
There have been plenty of players that put up numbers like that in the past and didn't win MVP. Phoenix didn't even have a top 2 record last season. Shaq should have won MVP in 2005, Dirk should have won in 2006.
-
Local High School Star
nash won more games than shaq in 05, turned a worst team than pre shaq miami into a better team than miami with shaq, there isnt a REALLY great argument you can make for each because that was the closest voting ever.
-
.
1st one no one was close to nash.
2nd one only lebron had a realistic arguement and played too immature too many times to deserve it.
if nash keeps these numbers up and has a few more games like last night that boggle the mind, then he'll have to be at least top 3 again.
-
Shazam!
Originally Posted by GOBB
Who did deserve it? Last season the race was close. I compare it to a Kentuck Derby finish where you gotta go to the tapes to see who won.
last season was a photo finish between two guys to use that analogy. Nash wasnt one of them.
-
Sixers|Eagles|Phillies
Originally Posted by WildStyle
There have been plenty of players that put up numbers like that in the past and didn't win MVP.
So? Then you name me who should have won it plus thier stats so i can counter the same damn argument.
-
the worst arguement is always "hey let's look back ten years to find out why nash shouldn't have won it."
or
"how many MVP's did stockton win?"
who gives a **** about the past?
-
Sixers|Eagles|Phillies
Originally Posted by raiderfan19
last season was a photo finish between two guys to use that analogy. Nash wasnt one of them.
Who was?
-
Sixers|Eagles|Phillies
Originally Posted by i seen hippos
the worst arguement is always "hey let's look back ten years to find out why nash shouldn't have won it."
or
"how many MVP's did stockton win?"
who gives a **** about the past?
Exactly...holds no relevance whatsoever.
-
Shazam!
Originally Posted by GOBB
Who was?
lebron and dirk. One of them should have won it.
-
...
im not mad at NAsh either... It just changed my opinion about the MVP as an award. I will now give it a lot less weight when comparing players. It is obvious that you can win it but not even be a top 7 player.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|