[KOBE143]

Mid-range shooting - Kobe 10, LeBron 4, Melo 8, Durant 9
Long-range shooting - Kobe 8, LeBron 4,Melo 8, Durant 8
Slashing ability - Kobe 7, LeBron 8, Melo 7, Durant 7
Post moves - Kobe 10, LeBron 4, Melo 8, Durant 5
Off the ball movement - Kobe 10, LeBron 4, Melo 8, Durant 8
First step - Kobe 7, LeBron 6, Melo 6, Durant 8
Strength/Speed/Overall Athleticism - Kobe 7, LeBron 10, Melo 8, Durant 8
Free throw shooting - Kobe 10, LeBron 4, Melo 10, Durant 10
Footwork - Kobe 10, LeBron 4, Melo 8, Durant 7

So here's my list base on above criteria:

Kobe
Melo
Durant




LeBron