Settling the Kobe vs Lebron debate once and for all

[ISHGoat]

Who is the better player, Lebron or Kobe?

I'll tally every post, whether it is legit, troll or alt.

:kobe: 19
:lebronamazed: 19

last updated vote: thesage

[ISHGoat]

:kobe:
outbreak
Cold soul
KembaWalker
sd3035
AnaheimLakers24
Showtime2001
Heavincent
stalkerforlife
monkeypox
WayOfWade
Mr. Jabbar
WTFdidNBAbigsGO
Gileraracer
houston
HOoopCityJones
masonanddixon
tragicbronson
Levity
90sgoat


:lebronamazed:
Papaya Petee
Dr Hawk
aj1987
ralph_i_el
raprap
kennethgriffin
pauk
toxicxr6
JEFFERSON MONEY
Fudge
34-24 Footwork
Horatio33
knicksman
Lebron23
PAOK
k0kakw0rld
Quickening
KirbyPls
thesage

[Papaya Petee]

LeBron

[outbreak]

Kobe

[Dr Hawk]

LeBron because his name has more letters

[outbreak]

Kobe

damn can't make more than one thread saying the same thing. OP said all votes count so can I just vote multiple times to off set the people who will vote with multiple accounts? that's what every ISH debate ends up being, like 4 people just voting on alts over and over.

[ISHGoat]

Kobe

damn can't make more than one thread saying the same thing. OP said all votes count so can I just vote multiple times to off set the people who will vote with multiple accounts? that's what every ISH debate ends up being, like 4 people just voting on alts over and over.

I'll only count 1 post from each username but if you have alts and are willing to vote many times, then more power to you.

[outbreak]

I'll only count 1 post from each username but if you have alts and are willing to vote many times, then more power to you.
I don't have alts but people with alts will just blow out any poll

[kennethgriffin]

theres a debate?

all i've ever heard from 99% of past/present players/coaches and hall of famers is that kobe is the closest thing to jordan we've ever seen and above lebron all time

i dont think theres been anything within the last few years to change that sentiment either

infact i think the whole 2 for 5 then 2 for 6 thing widened the gap

and 2 role players winning fmvp the last few years who matched up with lebron only made it worse


that ship sailed a long time ago

[ISHGoat]

^ Tldr but ill count your vote for kobe



I don't have alts but people with alts will just blow out any poll

yes but users on both sides are equally likely to have alts, so statistically this doesnt make a difference

[aj1987]

LeBron.

[Wade's Rings]

^ Tldr but ill count your vote for kobe




yes but users on both sides are equally likely to have alts, so statistically this doesnt make a difference

There are for sure more Bron Stans with Alts than Kobe Stans.

[Cold soul]

Kobe for now.

[ISHGoat]

There are for sure more Bron Stans with Alts than Kobe Stans.

Ok, if you guys want to come up with the sets of suspected alts then I will use my judgement for how many of their votes to count

[Wade's Rings]

Ok, if you guys want to come up with the sets of suspected alts then I will use my judgement for how many of their votes to count

Dubeta/lebronxrings/jt123 I know he has more accounts but their banned I believe.

Fudge/vaniia Not 100% sure on this

That's off the top of my head, for sure more.

[KembaWalker]

:kobe:

[Cold soul]

Dubeta/lebronxrings/jt123 I know he has more accounts but their banned I believe.

Fudge/vaniia Not 100% sure on this

That's off the top of my head, for sure more.

Why people have alts I'll never understand people must love to troll.

[sd3035]

Kobe

[KembaWalker]

Why people have alts I'll never understand people must love to troll.

It's so they have 'another' person to prop themselves up with :roll:

Phrases include....

rent free
ethered
meltdown
.... stans avoiding this thread like the plague

There's usually one main account and multiple sub accounts that I have never seen a valid argument from, it's either themselves OR it's some beta ass who's sole purpose is to lap up everything another poster says like a little dog

Welcome to ISH Stans class 101. Topic: Alts

This will be on the test.

[LAZERUSS]

Finally and once-and-for-all.

After this there can be no debate.

[Naero]

This all boils down to a popularity contest? :biggums:

What happened to debates wherein people put their GM-thinking caps on and logically appraised the better player to build a team around, as opposed to ring-counting, citing commendatory quotations, and a player's flashiness? :confusedshrug:

[ralph_i_el]

LeBron. After this thread, anyone who discusses this topic should be banned, exiled from earth, and their family sent to gulags for 3 generations

[AnaheimLakers24]

Kobe

[Wade's Rings]

Why people have alts I'll never understand people must love to troll.


It's so they have 'another' person to prop themselves up with :roll:

Phrases include....

rent free
ethered
meltdown
.... stans avoiding this thread like the plague

There's usually one main account and multiple sub accounts that I have never seen a valid argument from, it's either themselves OR it's some beta ass who's sole purpose is to lap up everything another poster says like a little dog

Welcome to ISH Stans class 101. Topic: Alts

This will be on the test.

Pretty much this. They use it to prop each other. The main account starts a thread the other is used to reply and troll.

This site is stupid in the sense that they don't have IP Bans. If 1 account gets banned they still have 4 more to troll with.



This all boils down to a popularity contest? :biggums:

What happened to debates wherein people put their GM-thinking caps on and logically appraised the better player to build a team around, as opposed to ring-counting, citing commendatory quotations, and a player's flashiness? :confusedshrug:

That ISH died awhile back.

[Straight_Ballin]

The only people that care about Kobe vs Bron are people that never saw Jordan play live. :lol

Unless the player is better than Jordan, IDGAF.

All these beta vs beta comparisons like Kobe be Bron gets old. At least 3balls post have merit in that he's comparing an alpha to a beta and exposes stans in the process.

[Cold soul]

The only people that care about Kobe vs Bron are people that never saw Jordan play live. :lol

Unless the player is better than Jordan, IDGAF.

All these beta vs beta comparisons like Kobe be Bron gets old. At least 3balls post have merit in that he's comparing an alpha to a beta and exposes stans in the process.

Jordan the greatest no doubt about it nothing wrong who debating the best since him, right?

[kennethgriffin]

The only people that care about Kobe vs Bron are people that never saw Jordan play live. :lol

Unless the player is better than Jordan, IDGAF.

All these beta vs beta comparisons like Kobe be Bron gets old. At least 3balls post have merit in that he's comparing an alpha to a beta and exposes stans in the process.

i saw jordan play live from around 1991 till 2003


he was really good. one of the best ever


are you trying to say its impossible not to be a jordan fan?

cause i was more of a fan of penny hardaway before kobe came along

[Akrazotile]

It's so they have 'another' person to prop themselves up with :roll:

Phrases include....

rent free
ethered
meltdown
.... stans avoiding this thread like the plague

There's usually one main account and multiple sub accounts that I have never seen a valid argument from, it's either themselves OR it's some beta ass who's sole purpose is to lap up everything another poster says like a little dog

Welcome to ISH Stans class 101. Topic: Alts

This will be on the test.



Meltdown

[raprap]

LeBron James

[kennethgriffin]

http://cs4571.vkontakte.ru/u1241345/-6/x_12f19042.jpg


for those of us who didn't care for mike

1995 was hilarious


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntwR8ZGmLJg


skip to 7:05

jordan down 2 in the elimination game 6 throwing the ball away into penny hardaways hands and losing the series

[KembaWalker]

Educating

FTFY.

[Showtime2001]

Kobe.

[kennethgriffin]

i'l vote lebron just to give him an outside chance

[GrapeApe]

http://cs4571.vkontakte.ru/u1241345/-6/x_12f19042.jpg


for those of us who didn't care for mike

1995 was hilarious


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntwR8ZGmLJg


skip to 7:05

jordan down 2 in the elimination game 6 throwing the ball away into penny hardaways hands and losing the series

I'd say he redeemed himself nicely over the next 3 years with 3 titles, 3 FMVP's, 2 MVP's, and 3 scoring titles.

Anyway, I think Kobe ranks higher all time, Lebron is the better player. Not sure which one the OP is looking for in terms of who is better.

[pauk]

Who the better individual player / talent / on court actual player is? (impact, prime, peak, allround game, completeness, versatility, combination of talent/skills/tools etc. whatever phrase you want to use) LeBron, i dont think its much arguable if you are impartial/objective about this, he is the better individual player, he gives a team overall just a bit MORE.

Who had the better / more accomplished career? I say LeBron, but this is more debatable.

So which of these two criterias are we going after? Both maybe?

For safeties sake / TL;DR: LeBron.

[Heavincent]

Kobe

[stalkerforlife]

Kobe.

Easily.

[red1]

chucking snitch vs choking diva. depends on what you value I guess

[monkeypox]

kobe

[kennethgriffin]

Who the better individual player / talent / on court actual player is? (impact, prime, peak, allround game, completeness, versatility, combination of talent/skills/tools etc. whatever phrase you want to use) LeBron, i dont think its much arguable if you are impartial/objective about this, he is the better individual player, he gives a team overall just a bit MORE.

Who had the better / more accomplished career? I say LeBron, but this is more debatable.

So which of these two criterias are we going after? Both maybe?

For safeties sake / TL;DR: LeBron.


except lebron has no talent asside from making layups. he has little to no impact on winning titles. his prime involves ring chasing, quitting, colluding, lockouts, bail outs, 1.5 out of 5 straight free trips to the finals from the pathetic east, his all around game is overrated considering he stunts the assist rate of his team and for a 6-9, 270 pound freak athlete, 6-7 rebounds isnt allot, he lacks a jumpshot, he freezes under pressure, hes shook of role players defending him, he lets them win finals mvps over him, he travels, he flops, he charges, hes an all time choker on the same level as wilt chamberlain.

i think theres plenty to argue. especially when your point of emphises is pulled out your a** like a monkey hurling feces at onlooking zoo dwellers

[WayOfWade]

I've got to go Kobe at the moment. The dude is #7 on my all-time list whereas LeBron is at like #11 at the moment

[Akrazotile]

i'l vote lebron just to give him an outside chance


Meltdown

[kennethgriffin]

:kobe:
outbreak
Cold soul
KembaWalker
sd3035
AnaheimLakers24
Showtime2001

:lebronamazed:
Papaya Petee
Dr Hawk
aj1987
ralph_i_el
raprap
kennethgriffin


lol i'm on team lebron in this one... lets make this a close battle

:cheers:

[Mr. Jabbar]

I may root for the KING on every game during the season but when I log on ish it is my duty to be honest. My vote -with great pain- goes to Kobe.

[toxicxr6]

Lebron is better than that goat chucker

[stalkerforlife]

Why can't people realize this debate won't be settled for at least another 3-5 seasons. Kobe at LeBron's age hadn't even won a title without Shaq yet

:biggums:

[jstern]

Kobe has never dominated the league like Lebron, and for so long. He also does not have as many memorable playoff moments as Lebron. Lebron is a top ten caliber player.

[Mr. Jabbar]

Kobe has never dominated the east like Lebron

fixed.

i still love lebron though. great human being :applause:

[TheMarkMadsen]

:biggums:


:oldlol: :oldlol:

[LikeABosh]

How about you have to have an IQ over the retard threshold for your vote to count? Lebron would win unanimously.

[JT123]

Kobe has never dominated the league like Lebron, and for so long. He also does not have as many memorable playoff moments as Lebron. Lebron is a top ten caliber player.
:applause: Kobe doesn't have any legendary playoff performances.

[TheMarkMadsen]

:applause: Kobe doesn't have any legendary playoff performances.

before or after you were born?

[AnaheimLakers24]

How about you have to have an IQ over the retard threshold for your vote to count? Lebron would win unanimously.
Nice of you to sacrifice your vote

[TheMarkMadsen]

Nice of you to sacrifice your vote

:roll: :roll:

[JEFFERSON MONEY]

Kobe.

Easily.

Burn in hell, Justin.





James.

[Hey Yo]

fixed.

i still love lebron though. great human being :applause:
Kobe possibly could have dominated the East, but chose to collude with the Lakers instead of letting the Nets draft him.

He chose the pine instead of the hardwood his first 2 years. Could have had his own team instead of waiting 8yrs while riding coattails.

[WTFdidNBAbigsGO]

Kobe All Day 5>2

[Fudge]

LeBron James.

Not even a debate.

[Gileraracer]

Huge Lebrun fan here but

5 rings in the WC >>>>>>>>>>>>>> 2 rings in the weak EC


Taking that L again :(

[34-24 Footwork]

Although kobe has won more in a tougher conference and played against better competition, I am bald and have a small p3nis. Therefore, Lebron has my vote.

[kennethgriffin]

Kobe has never dominated the league like Lebron, and for so long. He also does not have as many memorable playoff moments as Lebron. Lebron is a top ten caliber player.


1.5 rings

a lockout title

and a ray allen title


DOMINANT



who needs prime dwyane wade or chris bosh anyway

[houston]

Kobe for now.



yup

[Mr. Jabbar]

it hurts me to see KING james go down like this, flashes of <insert year> finals..:( kobe wins we get it, can some mod lock this thread already please?

[HOoopCityJones]

Kobe

[Horatio33]

LeBron

[knicksman]

Im feeling dumb right now so bran

[masonanddixon]

Kobe is obviously better. The only people that think Lebron is as good as or better than Kobe are people who never saw Kobe play or those under the age of 16.

[Lebron23]

Lebron James

[knicksman]

Kobe is obviously better. The only people that think Lebron is as good as or better than Kobe are people who never played ball in their lives.
Fixed

[PAOK]

the one with the receding hairline

[tragicbronson]

Kobe of course

:kobe:

[stalkerforlife]

Nice of you to sacrifice your vote

Dead.

:roll:

[k0kakw0rld]

LeBron...duh!

[Quickening]

lebron

[Bankaii]

Fixed
Please post a video of you attempting to play ball.
Just a layup is fine it'll be pathetic enough for a good laugh.

[KirbyPls]

Lebron. Kobe is great though as well.

[Levity]

never been a vienna sausage type of guy, so ill go with bean.

[thesage]

Lebron

[90sgoat]

Kobe

[riseagainst]

Kobron.
LeKobe.

[GoatBoy]

Mamba

[Dbrog]

As of today Kobe no question in my mind. Bron will get there though...

[Doranku]

Kobe.

[kennethgriffin]

sorry guys

this thread is officially taken over



http://www.easypolls.net/poll.html?p=55f9b7e3e4b0a042a1df639a


official poll ^^^^^^^^^^

[kennethgriffin]

http://insidehoops.com/forum/showthread.php?p=11713036&posted=1#post11713036

^^^^ link to real polling thread


get away from all these alt accounts